Bliley Brown & Williamson
Confidential Communication From B&W Outside Counsel and Other Tobacco Company Counsel, with Whom B&W Maintains A Common Legal Interest, Reflecting Legal Advice and Attorney Opinion Work Product Regarding Funding of Ctr Special Projects Research
Fields
- Type
- LETTER
- Author
- Shinn, William W. (TI Communications; Shook, Hardy, CTR Attorney)TI Communications Committee and was also a lawyer for CTR. William W. Shinn worked for Shook, Hardy & Bacon.
- Recipient
- Stevens, A.
- Ahrensfeld, T.
- Crohn
- Henson, M.A.
- Pepples, Ernest, J.D. (BW General Counsel and Sr. VP)
- Ahrensfeld, T.
- Copied
- Greer, J.
- Holtzman, A.
- Brown, J.
- Jacob, E.
- Holtzman, A.
Document Images
Reprinted frq~ ~e Archives of Environmental Health
~ rch 1970, Volume 20
Copyright~, O, American Medical Association
Metabolic Changes Associated With the
Cessation of Cigarette Smoking
Stanley C. Glauser, MD, Phl); Elinor M. Glauser, MD; Marcus M. Reidenberg, MD;
Ben F. Rusy, M D; and Ronald J. Tallarida, PhD, Philadelphia

377
Metabolic Changes Associated With the
Cessation of Cigarette Smoking
Stanley C. Glauser, M D , P h D ; E linor M. Glauser, M D ; Marcus M. Reidenberg, M D ;
Ben F. Rusy, M D; and Ronald J. Tallarida, PhD, Philadelphia
The person who stops smoking frequently gains
weight in the succeeding weeks. To study this
phenomenon, subjects were observed before and
one month after the cessation of smoking. Slatis-
tically significant increases were found in the
body weight and body surface area while there
were statistically significant decreases in the pro-
rein-bound iodine level (PBI), oxygen consump-
tion, heart rate, 30-minute postprandial blood
glucose level, and the serum calcium level. These
metabolic changes following the cessation of
smoking may be one of ths rsasons for the weight
gain observed.
THE adverse effects of cigarette smoking
on the health of the individual have been
well established.1 Much effort has gone into
convincing cigarette smokers that they
should stop smoking, since the cessation of
smoking has been shown to reverse some of
the adverse effects of smoking.~ The person
who stops smoking frequently gains weight
in the succeeding weeks or months. This
unwanted weight gain is often attributed to
increased food intake due to psychological
factors related to the cessation of smoking.
The cause of this weight gain is, in fact,
unknown. Our study was carried out to see
if the cessation of smoking was associated
with any gross metabolic changes that could
be, in part, responsible for the weight gain.
Submitted for publication May 25, 1969; accepted
Sept 30.
From the Department of Pharmacology, Temple
University School of Medicine. Philadelphia.
Reprint requests to 3400 N Broad St, Philadel-
phia 19140 (Dr. Glauser).
Methods
Seven male cigarette smoking scientists vol-
unteered to participate in this study. Each had
previously participated in pulmonary studies
and was thoroughly familiar with the testing
procedure. The entire battery of tests was car-
tied out on each subject at two different times.
Tests were made during the period in which
the volunteer was smoking and again after he
had not smoked for one month.
The subjects fasted and did not smoke for 12
hours prior to the battery of tests. They came
to the laboratory and assumed a supine posi-
tion for a one-half hour rest. This position was
maintained for the entire experimental period.
Following the initial rest, the subject breathed
through a Hans Rudolph high velocity one-way
breathing valve. A three-minute period of quiet
breathing of room air through the apparatus
was followed by a seven-minute collection peri-
od. During this test period, air was inspired
from a Tissot spirometer and expired gas was
collected in a Douglas bag. The respiratory rate
was determined during this test period. Sam-
ples of inspired and expired gas were collected
Table 1.--Smoking History of Subiects in Study
Subjects Years Smoked Packs per Day Cough
1 13 1.5 none
2 I 0 1 .O none
3 22 1.0 none
4 8 1.5 positive
5 18 2.0 positive
6 8 1.25 none
7 I0 1.5 none
Average 12.7 1.4
SD 5.0 0.3
Arch, Enuiron Health--Vol 20, March 1970

378
( (
CESSATION OF CIGARETTE SMOKING--GLAUSER ET AL
Table 2.--Measurement of Age, Height, Weight, BSA,* Temperature, Blood Pressure, and
Weight,? Ib (kg)
BSA (meters squared)~:
Height,
Subject Age in (cm) Before
After Before After
1 30 72.25 (180.6) 209.5 (104.8)
214,0 (107) 2.16 2.19
2 27 70.25 (175.6) 191.0 (95.5)
194,0 (97) 2.05 2.06
3 43 71.50 (178.8) 213.0 (106.5)
214,0 (107) 2.17 2.17
4 28 67.50(168.8) 154.5 (77.3)
164,0 (82) 1.82 1.86
5 35 69.75 (174.3) 167.0 (83.5)
172.0 (89) 1.92 1.94
6 30 70.00(175.0) 167.0 (83.5)
167,0 (83.5) 1.92 1.92
7 27 70.25 (175.6) 216.0 (108)
238.0 (I 19) 2.15 2.24
Average 31.4 70.21 (175.5) 188.3 (94.2)
194.7 (97.4) 2.03 2.05
SD 5.4 1.38 23.6
26.3 0.13 0.14
* BSA, body surface area.
t Both values are statistically significant and different (P < 0.05).
~ Both values are statistically significant and highly different (P < 0.025).
Table 3.--Measurement of Hematocrit, Glucose, Serum Cholesterol, PBI, Hemoglobin, Serum
Fasting Blood Glucose, 30-rain Blood Glucose,
Serum Cholesterol,
Hematocrit rag/100 ml mg/100 ml*
rag/100 ml
Subject Before After Before After
Before After Before After
1 42.0 46.3 80 85
108 76 282 213
2 44.0 44.4 82 92
137 150 185 199
3 43.7 46.3 100 95
175 161 310 312
4 43 42 82 79
120 109 226 263
5 46.1 44.8 83 85
122 122 308 265
6 43.8 41.4 90 86
148 118 182 126
7 46.7 44.2 92 86
148 130 204 209
Average 44.2 44.2 87 87
] 37 123 242 227
SD 1.5 1.8 6.7 4.8
20.8 25.8 52 55
* Both values are statistically significant and different (P < 0.05).
% Both values are statistically significant and highly different (P < 0.025).
Table 4.~Measurement of 0~_ Consumption, CO~ Production, RespiratorF Quotient and Rate, and Oxygen
Oxygen Consumption,
(ml Oz/min at STPD)*
Carbon Dioxide Production,
(ml COz/min at STPD)
Respiratory Quotient*
Subject Before After Before
After Before After
1 295 273 199
233 0.67 0.85
2 284 204 210
176 0.74 0.86
3 311 275 237
191 0.73 0.69
4 214 247 185
213 0.86 0.86
5 298 256 231
206 0.78 0.80
6 262 249 179
183 0.68 0.73
7 317 315 251
269 0.79 0.85
Average 283 260 213
210 0.75 0.81
SD$ 33 31 25
30 0.06 0.06
* Both values are statistically significant and different (P < 0.05). STPD, standard temperature and
pressure, dry.
Arch Enuiron Health--VoZ 20, March 1970

CESSATION OF CIGARETTE SA{OKING--GLAUSER ET AL
Heart Rate Before and After Cessation of Smoking
379
Temperature, F (C)
Blood Pressure (mm Hg)
Heart Rate (Beats/min)˘
Before After Before
After Before After
97.0 (36.1) 97.2 (36.2) 126/88
122/90 65 65
97.6 (36.4) 97.8 (36.6) 100/60
112/58 43 42
98.2 (36.8) 97.6 (36.4) 124/86
126/86 65 52
97.6 (36.4) 97.4 (36.3) 110/66
112/60 68 68
97.6 (36.4) 97.6 (36.4) 108/68
122/78 62 58
97.8 (36.6) 98.0 (36.7) 112/70
108/64 53 53
97.6 (36.4) 97.4 (36.3) 110/70
116/78 65 60
97.6 (36.4) 97.6 (36.4) 113/73
117/73 60 57
0.3 0.2 8/10
6/12 8 8
Calcium, and Difference Between 30-minute and Fasting Blood Glucose
Serum
Calcium,
PBI, #g/100 ml* Hgb, gm/100 ml mg/100 ml˘
30-min Blood Glucose-Fasting
Blood Glucose, mg/100 ml*
Before After Before After Before
After Before After
4.8 4.7 12.1 16.3 10.84
10.00 28
4.7 3.7 13.9 14.5 9.84
9.66 55 58
4.2 4.4 13.6 14.8 10.20
10.42 75 66
6.2 6.3 13.0 13.7 10.04
10.10 38 30
5.6 4.5 13.6 13.3 10.50
9.32 39 37
3.7 3.7 13.7 13.2 9.22
8.40 58 32
6.2 4.7 13.1 12.3 10.74
9.84 56 44
5.1 4.6 13.3 14.0 10.20
9.70 50 37
0.9 0.8 0.6 1,2 0.50
0.60 14.6 22,4
Consumption Before and After Cessation of Smoking
Respiratory Rate, Oz Consumption/meters
(Breaths/min) squared
Before After Before After
8 6 137 125
7 10 139 99
4 4 143 127
13 16 118 133
10 8 155 132
12 16 ]36 130
10 8 147 141
9 10 139 127
3 4 11 12
under mercury in a tonometer and analyzed in
a Scholander:~ gas analyzer. Inspired and ex-
pired gas volumes were measured in a W~ssot
spirometer and corrected to standard condi-
tions.
Oral temperatures were measured with a
clinical thermometer. Blood pressure readings
were made on an aneroid type sphygmomanom-
eter. A six-lead electrocardiogram was taken
using the limb leads. Venous blood samples
were collected. Tubes without anticoagulant
were used 5o collect blood for serum cholester-
ol, serum calcium, and serum protein-bound
iodine (PBI) levels. Anticoagulated blood was
used fasting to obtain the following values:
blood glucose, hemoglobin, and hematocrit. The
volunteer was then given 150 ml of a 50%
glucose solution in ice. Thirty minutes later,
another venous blood sample was drawn for
Arch Environ Health--Vd 20, March 1970

380
CESSATION OF CIGARETTE
glucose determination. The subjects were then
permitted to stand up and their height and
weight were measured.
The blood glucose analysis was done by the
ferricyanide reduction method as adapted for
the autoanalyzer. The PBI analysis was done
by the wet ash and ceric ammonium sulfate-ar-
senous acid method, as adapted for the autoan-
alyzer. The analysis of cholesterols was done by
the method of Pauvionsky.4 The hemoglobin
concentration was determined spectrophoto-
metrically, using Drabkin's reagent.5 The hema-
tocrit readings were done using microcapfllary
tubes. The serum calcium levels were determined
by atomic absorption spectroscopy,s
The analysis of data was done by means of a
paired comparison, with each subject serving as
his own control.
Table 1 identifies the seven male scientist
volunteers and shows that they smoked an
average of 12.7 years and consumed as aver-
age of 1.4 packs of cigarettes per day. By
history, only two acknowledged having a
chronic cough.
Table 2 gives the age and height of the
subjects, and weight before and after cessa-
tion of snmking. The mean age was 31.4
years, the mean height was 178.7 cm (70.21
inches). The mean weight before cessation
of smoking was 83.29 kg (188.3 lb), while
after cessation of smoking it increased to
87.33 kg (194.7 lb). Table 2 also gives the
body surface area, temperature, blood pres-
sure, and heart rate before and after the
cessation of smoking. The body surface area
was determined from the nomogram of
DuBois.z The mean body surface area before
cessation of smoking was 2.03 meters
squared, while after cessation of smoking, it
rose to 2.05 meters squared. This difference
is due to the increase in body weight. The
mean body temperature both before and af-
ter cessation of smoking was 97.6 F (36.4 C).
The mean blood pressure before cessation of
smoking was 113/73 mm Hg, while after
cessation of smoking, it was 117/73. The
mean heart rate before cessation of smoking,
as determined from the ECG record, was 60
beats per minute, while after cessation of
smoking, this decreased to 57 beats per min-
ute.
In Table 3, values are given for hemato-
crit, fasting blood glucose, 30-minute post-
SMOKING--GLAUSER ET AL
prandial blood glucose, serum cholesterol,
PBI, hemoglobin concentration of blood,
and serum calcium. The mean hematocrit
reading before and after cessation of smok-
ing was 44.2~. The mean fasting blood
glucose level before and after cessation of
smoking was 87 mg/100 ml. The mean 30-
minute postprandial blood glucose level was
137 mg/100 ml before cessation of smoking,
while after cessation of smoking this value
dropped to 123 rag/100 ml. The mean serum
cholesterol level before cessation of smoking
was 242 rag/100 ml and after cessation of
smoking was 10.2 mg/100 ml, while after
level before cessation of smoking was
5.1~g/100 ml while after cessation of smok-
ing, it was 4.6ttg/100 ml. Before cessation of
smoking, the mean hemoglobin value was
13.3 gm]100 ml, while after cessation of
smoking it was 14.0 gm/100 ml. The mean
sertan calcium level before cessation of
smoking was 10.2 mg/100 ml, while after
cessation of smoking this had declined to 9.7
rag/100 ml.
Table 4 summarizes the respiratory data
and lists the oxygen consumption, carbon
dioxide production, respiratory quotient,
and respiratory rate. The mean oxygen con-
sumption before cessation of smoking was
283 ml/min, while after cessation of smok-
ing the value had dropped to 260 ml/min.
The average carbon dioxide production be-
fore cessation of smoking was 213 ml/min,
while after cessation of smoking it was 210
ml/min. The respiratory quotient was calcu-
lated for each individual by dividing his
carbon dioxide production by his oxygen
consumption. The mean respiratory quotient
before cessation of smoking was 0.75, while
after cessation of smoking this value had
risen to 0.81. The average respiratory rate
before cessation of smoking was 9 breaths
per minute and after cessation of smoking
was 10 breaths per minute. The electrocar-
diographic pattern of each patient taken
after the cessation of smoking was the same
as that taken during smoking.
Conunent
The following factors were significantly
changed following the cessation of smoking:
body weight increased, body surface area
increased, heart rate decreased, 30-minute
postprandial blood glucose level decreased,
Arch Environ HeaIth--Vol 20. March 1970

CESSATION OF C RETTE SMOKING--GLAUSER ET AL ~
381
PBI decreased, serum calcium level de-
creased, oxygen consumption decreased, and
the respiratory quotient increased. There
was also a significant drop in the increase in
blood glucose following a glucose meal.
Each of the subjects, with one exception,
gained weight during the month between
tests. The subject who maintained a con-
stant weight had a marked increase in activ-
ity levels. All but one subject had a decrease
in their basal oxygen consumptions. It is
commonly accepted that the weight gain
following the cessation of smoking is due to
an increase in food consumption without a
parallel increase in physical activity. We
interpret our results to indicate that a meta-
bolic change occurs following the cessation
of smoking. This change causes a decreased
basal oxygen consumption. With no change
in caloric intake or physical activity, this
metabolic change would cause weight gain.
We think that this metabolic change is par-
tially responsible for the weight gain ob-
served in our subjects. Other evidence for a
metabolic change was the decreased hyper-
glycemic response to a glucose meal while
the fasting blood glucose level remained con°
stant; the decreased PBI level; the de-
creased serum calcium level; and a small,
but statistically significant, decreased heart
rate.
Other known changes produced by smok-
ing include an increased heart rate,S,9 block-
age of normal metabolism of tryptophan,TM
induction of benzpyrene hydroxylase in pla-
cental tissue,11 and decrease in carbonic an-
hydrase in fetuses.12 Nicotine has been
shown to cause an increase in tryptophan
pyrrolase and in the rate of metabolism of
ethylmorphine, norcodeine, and aniline.TM
The metabolic changes following the ces-
sation of smoking described in this study
may be one of the reasons for the weight
gain observed. The idea that weight gained
after smoking is stopped is due solely to
increased caloric intake without parallel in-
creased physical activity is not necessarily
true.
This work was supported in part by PHS grants
AM-10072, He-08752, and FR~)0349, and a grant-
in-aid from the Southeastern Pennsylvania Hear~
Association.
References
1. The Health Consequences of Smoking. Surgeon
Genemrs Report, a Public Health Service Review,
1967.
2. Hammond EC: The effects of smoking. Sci
Amer 207:39-51, 1962.
3. Scholander PE: Analyzer for accurate estima-
tions of respiratory gases in one half cubic centime-
tar samples. J Biol Chem 167:235-250, 1947.
4. Pauvionsky P: Moderately simple cholesterol
method eliminating intermediate extractions. Clin
Chern 8:444, 1962.
5. Drabkin DL, Austin JH: Spectrophotometric
studies: Preparation from washed blood cells; nitric
oxide hemoglobin and sulfhemoglobin. J Biol Chem
112:51-65, 1935.
6. Willis JB: Determination of calcium and mag-
nesium in urine by atomic absorption spectroscopy.
Anal Chem 33:556-559, 1961.
7. DuBois EF: Basal Metabolism in Health and
Disease, ed 3. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger Publish-
ers, 1924, pp 145-200.
8. Krumholz RA, Chevalier RB, Ross JC:
Changes in cardiopulmonary functions related to
abstinenco from smoking. Ann Intern Med 62:197-
207, 1965.
9. Chevalier RB, Bowers, JA, Bondurant S, et al:
Circulatory and venti!atory effects of exercise in
smokers and nonsmokers. J Appl Physiol 18:357-
360, 1963.
10. Kerr WK, Barkin M, Levers PE, et al: The
effect of cigarette smoking on bladder carcinogens in
man. Canad Med Assoc J 93:1-7, 1965.
11. Welch RM, Harrison YE, Conney AH, et al:
Cigarette smoking: Stimulatory effect on metabo-
lism of 3, 4-Benzpyrene by enzymes in human
placenta. Science 160:541-542, 1968.
12. Mantell CD: Smoking in pregnancy: The role
played by carbonic anhydrase. New Zeal Med J
63:601-603, 1964.
13. Ruddon RW, Cohen AM: Alteration of en-
zvmo activity in rat liver after nicotine administra-
tion. Fed Proc 28:418, 1969.
Arch Ent,iron ttealth--Vol 20, March 1970
Printed and Publisned in the United States of America

---
