Product Design
Unextracted Nicotine as Potential Source of NNK in Smoke: A Proposal for Study
Abstract
Proposes a series of studies to identify the source of 4-Methylnitrosamino-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone [NNK] in smoke. Infers that unextracted nicotine may be the source and outlines research strategies. Asks for further discussions and developing a research plan in a timely fashion.
Fields
- Author
- Hempfling, Walter, Ph.D. (Associate Principal Scientist, PM, c. 1997)Reported to Robert A. Fenner,
- Recipient
- Carchman, Richard Allan, Ph.D. (PM Scientific Affairs, Research & Development VP)Philip Morris Director and worked in Scientific Affairs. Reported to Cathy ellis.
- Charles, James L., Ph.D. (PM, R&D VP, Pharmacologist, Industry Expert)
Vice President of Research and a scientist for Philip Morris, Inc. Vice President of Research for Philip Morris, Inc. in 1986 and then again from 1992 to 1993.- Ellis, Cathy Lynn, Ph.D. (PM VP of Worldwide Scientific Affairs)
Director of Research at Philip Morris U.S.A. in 1994. In 1997 was Senior VP of R&D at PM (2505370877). Osdene protégé.- Fenner, Robert A. (PM Director, Product Research & Technologies at PM (1997))
- Ferguson, R.
Technical Coordinator- Handy, B
1994 USA. Member of Coresta Task Force- Hassam, S. 1
- Haut, Steve (Former PM scientist)
Did research with Vedpal Mali on removing nicotine from tobacco plants was told by Cathy Ellis to alter lab notebooks (B. Campf 6/2/94).- Izac, R. 2
- Jenkins, Robert
Defense- Jensen, M.
- Keene, C. 3
- Kinser, Robin Dale (Manager, Analytical Research, PM, 1997)
Joined PM in Sept. 1976 and prior to his position in 1997 was Manager of Product Research. Reported to Richard P. Solana (2505370877)- Kroustalis, C.
Associate Professional- Leyden, D.
- *Lilly, A. C. (use Arnys Clifton, Jr., Ph.D.)
Senior Professional- Morgan, Robert A. (Philip Morris, Inc. Scientist)
Robert A. Morgan was a Philip Morris, Inc. scientist.- Shafer, K. 4
- Warfield, Al H. (PM)
- Watson, Diane
- Whidby, Jerry Frank, Ph.D. (PM Analytical Chemist, Industry Expert)
Philip Morris Scientist - Charles, James L., Ph.D. (PM, R&D VP, Pharmacologist, Industry Expert)
- Hypothesis
- Nicotine transport, transfer, and uptakeDesign changes which alter nicotine delivery or effect how the product causes and maintains dependence, including transfer of nicotine from tobacco to smoke, and uptake into the body.
- Smoke constituent testing
Development of methods for measurement of gas and particulate yields in mainstream and sidestream smoke. - Smoke constituent testing
- Keyword
- Extractable nicotine
- Pyrolysis
- Unextractable nicotine
- Pyrolysis
- Smoke Constituent
- NNK (4-Methylnitrosamino-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone)
- Nicotinoids
- Operation/Project
- Project 6908 5
- Named Organization
- Philip Morris Incorporated (Philip Morris U.S.A.) (a wholly-owned subsidiary of Philip Morris Co., Inc.)A wholly-owned subsidiary of Philip Morris Co., Inc.
- Subject
- Experimental Technology (Technology)
- nicotine technology
- Smoke Nicotine (Measures)
- Test/Smoke Constituents (Testing)
- Transfer to Smoke (Measures)
- nicotine technology
Annotations
- 1. Hassam, S. Recipient
PM USA distribution list.
- 2. Izac, R. Recipient
PM USA distribution list.
- 3. Keene, C. Recipient
PM USA distribution list.
- 4. Shafer, K. Recipient
PM USA distribution list.
- 5. Project 6908 Operation/Project
- Description:
PM USA project designed to elucidate the relationship between unextracted nicotine [UN] and 4-Methylnitrosamino-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone [NNK] in smoke.
- Description:
Document Images
PHILIP MORRIS U. S. A..
I', NiT E R' - O F' F I C' E C' O R R E S P O N D E N C E
Ri;chmosrd, Virginia
R'ESTRISITED1
D !ISiRIBUTION
Tb: Dr. A. Warfield Date: 2'5' April 1989
From: W. P. Hempfling
Subject: Unextracted nicotine as potential source of NNK in s2noke:~ a
proposal for study
The search for the identity or identities of "unextracted nicotine",
which, may be a source or sources of'NNK in smoke, comprises the need to
answer three questions. The resoliution of those questions is addressed'in the following.
A. Is there a correlation between UNiin base webs and NNK in sm©ke?
Strategv; Using base webs, the delivery of NNK in smoke of which is known,
measure contents of total nicotine, extractable nicotine and unextracted
nicotine. Compile a "nicotine balance". Compare values (original dry
weight basis) obtained with, values of NNK in smoke. Measure endogenous NNK
to estimate transfer into smoke.
1. Total nicotine (TN)
Extract base webs with 1 N NaOH, 900 C', 24 hr (.3x water wash) . Measure
nicotine content (by GC or HPLC, method to be determined), first extracting
combined aqueous portions with dichloromethane (DCM). This treatment sieems
to reveal the largest amount of'nicotine of any method now extant. Special
attention must be paid to the extent of solubilization of the tobacco fiber,
since an indication exists that nicotine remains bound to the small marc:
remaining after alkaline digestion.
It will be: useful to submit tobacco samples to ARD for estimations of
nicotine by the pyran procedure. If conditions of pyrolysis are identified'
that liberate significantly greater amounts of nicotine than does hot
alkaline digestion, those values should be used as the measure of TN.
2. Extractable nicotine (EN)
Extractions are designed to remove soluble nicotine without modifying
nicotine-containing compounds that might be present. r~
. ~
a. Extraot base webs (!SW) with neutral buffer (50 mM potassium phosphate, ~
pH 7) in the cold, 24 hr. Wash marc 3x with buffer and combine:. Reserve
marc. (~.
~
b. Extract BW with neutral buffier, 90'O C, 24 hr. Wash marc 3x with buffer ~
and combine. Reserve marc. ~
The aqueous extracts of a. and b. above are made 0.5 - 1 N with NaOH and 0
extracted 3x with DCM, and the DCM fraction assayed for nicotine content. ~

C. Extract: BW with methanol/10%: ammonia ,in the: co]Jd, 241 hr. Wash marc 3x
with methanol and combine. Reserve marc. Measure nicotine content
directly.
. Unextracted nicotine (UN)
we postulate the existence of two, forms of UN in BW': water-soluble and
water-insoluble. The latter form is bound in some manner to the cellulosic
tobacco matrix. Both forms yield nicotine in smoke upon combustion.,, and
upon prolonged exposure to hot alkali.
a . Water-soluble UN ('"Nic-X"').
Mix portions of extracts 2.a. and 2.b. (above) with NaOH to reach 1 N.
Heat at 9i0'O' C for 24' hr. Measure nicotine content of' 2.al2 and 2.b. ('DCM
extraction,) before andd after heating. The difference is the amount of Nic-
X.
b. Water-insioluble UN ('"Nic-Y'"').
Mix the (dried) mares from extractions 2. a., 2.b.. and 2'.c. with 1 N
NaOH and heat 0100 C) for 24 hr. ESctract aliiqiaots of the alkaline extractt
with DCM and measure nicotine content. That quantity is the amount of'Nic-
Y. Special attention must be paid to the extent of solubilization of the
tobacco fiber, since an indicationlexists that nicotine remains bound to the
small marc remaining after alkaline digestion.
. Nicotine balance
The sum of water-soluble nicotine (2.a. and 2.b.) plus their respective
Nic-X and Nic-Y contents should equal TN. This should also be true of the
methanol/ammonia-extracted material, unless part or all of Nic-X is soluble
in that reagent' (there is some reason to expect solubility in methanol -
Ref. 3) . A hot alkaline digestion of a portion of the methanol/ammonia
extract should be performed to test the solubility of' Nic-X in that
solution.
5. Minor alkaloids
The preparation of hot-alkali extracts of base webs for nicotine
estimation afford's the opportunity to examine their contents for the
presence of' otherwise unextracted forms of the minor alkaloids nornicotine
and anatabine. Should this be considiered desirable, sufficient material
ought to be available for those assays.
B. What is or are the chemical identity or identities of UN?
It seems to me highly important that we establish the chemical
identities of both, Nic-X and Nic-Y, especially if one or both of these
sources of nicotine is correlated with NNK:generation in smoke. Knowledge
of their chemical natures will enable us to infer experimentally testable
hypotheses about the means of NNK' generation at high temperatures.
Moreover, that information may suggest ways of treating tobacco, prior to
SCFE, in order to reduce or eliminate the unextracted forms of nicotine.

Strategv; Isolate the water-soluble forrki of UN (Nic-X) and determine its
chemical structure (mass spectrometry).. Subject the water-insoluble matrix
containing Nic-Y to treatment with enzymes that digest cellulose and protein
in an attempt to render the Nic-Y moiety or moieties sufficiently water-
soluble to employ separation methods that are to be worked out during Nic-X
isolation. Isolate the water-solubilized form of Nic-Y and determine its
chemical structure (further enzymatic: or cheznical degradation, masss
spectrometry).
1. Isolation of Nic-X
The raw material from which Nic-X will be isolated will be CEL. The
CEL~ (bright, burley or oriental) chosen for work-up will be identified by
measuring the content of Nic-X as already described (3.b., above), selecting,
that CEL with the highest Nic-X content. Nicotine will first be extracted
by rendering the solution alkaline ('ca. 01.5 N Naf9H)~ and mixing repeatedly
with DCM, (room temperature) for brief periods of time. It is possible that
Nic-X may be:solubZe.or partially soluble in DCM, and this must be initially
determined by performing a hot alkali digestion of the DCM extract (;after
removing DCM); andiof the DCM-extracted CEL. If Nic-X is found to be soluble
in DCM, the: organic extract can be used as a, starting point for further
(simpler) purification. We ought to consider further solvent extraction
schemes if'this~be true. If Nic-X proves not to be soluble in DCM, the
aqueous fractionifrom which nicotine has been removed will serve as starting
material. T will assume: the latter to be the caBe, because it will present
the:greater difficulty in isolation.
The presence of Nic-X in various fractions arisingi during, purification
will be determinedi as in A.3.b., above.
Isolation, ought to: be.achieved by (in sequenceY the following steps,
preceded by high-speed centrifugation in the cold and micropore filtration
to~remove particulate matter.
a,. Gell permeation chromatography in the cold using BioGel P-4 or similar
matrix allowingiresolution below 10 kD (acetate buffer, pH 5).
b. Cation-exchange:chromatography (strong resin) in the cold at pH 5
(acetate: buffer), using either an increasing,gradient of acetic acid (01 to 1
M) or NaOH (0 to 1 M) ;
c. Fbliliowing neutralization of the combined fractions containing Niic-X,.
HPLC reversed-phase: separation (C'l e) with methanoli/water or
acetonitrile/water, or other gradients (to be determined)1, at suitable pH
values. UV absorption by the nicotine moiety can be used to monitor the
progress of chromatography.
Should Nic-X be soluble in DCM or methanol, the reversed-phase HPLC''
separation will be applied directly to solvent-free fractions, and fully
orgianic or polar org,anic/water gradients may be employed (to be determined
by consultation)..
The most hig,hly purified Nic-X fractions will be submitted for
examination by mass spectrometry. In addition, and foLlowing hot alkaline
digestion of a portion of the purified material, reversed-phase HPLC will be
used to separate free nicotine from other components thereby liberated,
which will themselves be submitted for MS analysis. It will be useful to
subject Nic-X to treatment with P-glucosidase (see C. below).
-3-

When adequate quantities of purified Nic-X are available, they will be
tested in cigarettes to determine if'NNK is produced owing to Nic-X
addition (matrix to be determine'd).
2. Isolation of water-soluble forms of Nic-Y
Prepare hot-water-extracted base webs (A.2.b., above) that are
essentially free of EN and Nic-X. Subject these Nic-Y-bealring materials
(well-commin'uted), to digestion with enzymes under appropriate conditions
(from the literature) of pH, ionic strength, temperature and time. Since
treatment with one kind of hydrolase may render the remaining insoluble
fraction more susceptible to digestion by one with a different substrate
spec:ificity, the enzymes should be applied singly and in succession. Fbr
example, digestion with, endoprotease may render the matrix more susceptible
to cellulase action, or the reverse.
Suitable commerc'ially available enzymes include::
a. cellulase from Trichoderma viride;
b. endoprotease (e. g. Pronase from Streptomvices)s'
c. phenolase (tyrosinase) from potato;;
d. pectinesterase from orange peel; and
e. pectinase from Aspercrillus niare;r.
Success in liberating water-soluble forms of Nic-Y will be indicated by
digesting the supernatant portion (following centrifugation) with hot alkali
(A.3.b., above), and showing the presence of nicotine in the digest. Of'
course, the possible presence of" nicotine prior to alkaline digestion will
also be determined. Isolation of soluble Nic-Y'will proceed as outlined for
Nic-X ('B.l.a., b., above), with modifications dictated by the results'of
enzyme digestions, which will allow the inference of the types of compounds
associated with nicotine in the bound!state. Mass spectrometric analysis
will be applied when suitable isolates are available.
C. Can nicotine-N-glucoside serve as an esperimntal analog of Nic-X?
At lea~st two p'ublications have appeared (1,2) which describe the
presence of nicotinic acid-Nrglucoside in tobacco and parsley cells.
This compound releases nicotinic acid when treated with A-g,lucosidiase,
results reminiscent of C. Kroustalis"s earlier finding (3) that suchh
enzymatic treatment of tobacco fractions releases nicotine. We need to be
attentive to the possibilit y that a nicotine-N-glycoside may actually be
Nic-X, Nic-Y (in a water-insoluble form due to linkage to the cellulosic
matrix) , or bothi. According,ly, purified Nic-X fractions will be digested
with Q-glucosidase (3) and the products identified. Recent consultation
with Dr. A. Wol'if has produced the opinion that such a compound will likel!y
possess at least some of'the properties of Nic-X; namely, release of
nicotine in hot alkali but not in hot acid.
In any event, we should request the preparation of nicotine-N-
glucoside, as a possible analog of Nic-X, for smoking studies (NTiKK
production). One might also imagine that other potential NNK precursors
could exist as giycos'ides (e.g. pseudooxynicotine).
I do not mean to aver that Nic-X or Nic-Y i_s a glycoside or glycosides..
~ 1.
Extractions and digestions ought to be designed so that other modes of
nicotine immobilization might also be revealed if they in fact exist.
~.
-4-

I look forwa~rd to discussions with you and members of Project 6908 to
develop a detailediplan of operation with time lines consonant with the
importance of'this matter.
Refesencew
1. Mizusaki, S., Tanabe, Y., Kisaki, T. and T'aQnaki, E. Metabolism of
nicotinic:acidiin tobacco plants. Phytochem., 9, 549 - 554, 1970.
2. Upmeier, B., Thomzik, J. and Barz, W. Nicotinic acid-I?Trglucoside in
heterotrophic!parsley cel!l suspension cultures. Phytochem. 27, 3489 - 3493,
1988.
3. Kroustalis, C. Personal communication, 4 April 1989.
Copies to,: Pt. Carchman R. Izac
J.
C'.
X.
X.
B.
S.
S. Charles
Ellis
Fenner
Ferguson
Handy
Hassam,L,/
Haut R.
N.
C.
R.
C.
D.
A. Jenkins
Jensen
Keene
Kinser
Kroustalis
Leyden
Lilly
R. Morgan
K. Shafer
D. Watson
J. Whidby
